Growing Up Without a Father: What It Does to Girls and the Women They Become
I've written about what growing up without a father does to boys. The emails and messages that came back surprised me. A lot of them were from women. Women saying, more or less, "What about us?"
Fair question. So let's talk about it.
First, the honest part. This isn't exactly my story. My father was in my life, and that was its own problem. Drugs, alcohol, violence. My parents divorced, got back together, and divorced again. By the end of high school I'd been through eight schools and about fifteen homes. So I know what it is to grow up with a dad-shaped hole, even if mine had a dad standing in it some of the time.
And I've spent my whole adult life around this stuff. In therapy since I was five. Talking about mental health on stages, on podcasts, with anyone who'll listen. What I hear from women who grew up without a father, or with one who checked out, has a pattern to it. And the research backs it up.
What the research says
In 2019, family researchers D. Scott Sibley and Katie Granger sat down with 24 young women and asked them about their fathers and their relationships. They wrote it up for the Institute for Family Studies. The women whose fathers were absent described more difficulty trusting other people, and said they weren't sure what to expect in romantic relationships. The authors put it simply: father absence "seemed to have a negative impact on the women in our study."
It's a small study. One study never tells the whole story. But it lines up with what so many women describe, and with what I've seen in my own family: when the first man in your life leaves, or never shows up, your brain writes a rule. And the rule usually sounds something like, "People leave. Don't count on anyone."
That's the lie my brain was telling me too. I just learned it in a different house.
7 ways it can show up in women as adults
Trouble trusting. Even good partners. Even good friends. Part of you is always waiting for the other shoe to drop.
People pleasing. If you're useful enough, easy enough, low-maintenance enough, maybe they'll stay.
Picking the unavailable ones. The guy who's hot and cold feels familiar. Familiar can feel like love, even when it isn't.
Leaving first. If you end it before they can, at least you're in control. I wrote more about that in How Abandonment Issues Push Away the People You Love.
Being the strong one. A lot of daughters grew up helping a single mom hold everything together. You learned early that your feelings could wait. Some of you are still waiting.
Needing constant reassurance. A late text back turns into a whole story in your head about what you did wrong.
A quiet voice that says you weren't worth staying for. This is the big one. And it's the biggest lie of all.
Women get told a different story
Boys get told big boys don't cry. Girls get told they're too emotional. Too sensitive. Too much. So a lot of women carry this alone, because saying it out loud feels like proving the critics right.
It's not too much. It's a normal reaction to a real loss. A father who leaves, or dies, or is there but not really there, is a loss, even if nobody ever called it that.
5 things that help
Name it. All naming it is, is saying out loud, "This is the old fear talking." When your partner is late and your stomach drops, you can say, "This is my abandonment stuff, not a fact."
Find a therapist. I call therapy a trainer for your brain. You wouldn't try to fix a torn muscle by yourself. This is the same.
Write down the evidence. Keep a list of the people who showed up for you. Friends who stayed. Partners who came back. When the lie gets loud, read it.
Practice asking for what you need. Small stuff first. "Can you text me when you land?" is not needy. It's a normal ask.
Grieve the dad you didn't get. This sounds strange, but a lot of healing starts when you stop pretending it didn't matter.
For managers and HR leaders
Some of the hardest-working people on your team are running on this. The over-performer who never says no. The person who panics when a meeting invite shows up with no agenda. You don't need to know their story to help. Be clear and consistent. Send the unprompted note that says, "You did great on this." It lands harder than you think.
You weren't the reason
If your father left, it wasn't because you weren't enough. I know you've heard that before. I'm going to keep saying it until it sticks, because nobody said it to a lot of us when we needed to hear it.
Want the other side of this? Read Growing Up Without a Father: What It Does to Boys and the Men They Become and Childhood Trauma Doesn't Stay in Childhood.
If you are in crisis or thinking about hurting yourself, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. More resources are on my resources page.
Sources: D. Scott Sibley and Katie Granger, How Fathers Influence Their Daughters' Romantic Relationships, Institute for Family Studies, July 2019. The Institute for Family Studies is a research group that advocates for marriage and family stability.
Jason Prinzo is a mental health keynote speaker who talks to companies, women's leadership groups, conferences and associations about anxiety, depression, childhood trauma and asking for help. To bring him to your event, get in touch here.



Comments